Which Links to Your Old Domain Are Worth the Trouble to Update
After you move to a better domain, not every old link needs chasing. Here's how to tell which backlinks are worth updating and which ones your redirects already handle.
You moved your website to a better domain name. Good. Now you're staring at a list of every place that still links to the old one, and it's longer than you thought. Directory listings. A supplier's partner page. That newspaper story from three years ago. The chamber of commerce. A couple of blogs you forgot you were ever on.
Here's the honest answer most people won't give you: you don't have to update all of them. If your redirects are set up right, most links keep working on their own. The job isn't to chase every link. It's to pick the handful that actually matter and fix those.
Let's sort out which links are worth your time when you're updating backlinks after changing domain names — and which you can leave alone.
First, understand what your redirect already does
When you do a domain move the right way, you point every page on the old domain to the matching page on the new one with a 301 redirect. A 301 tells both people and Google, "this moved permanently — go here instead."
That means an old link doesn't break. Someone clicks it, and they land on your new site. Google follows it too, and passes along most of the credit that link was giving your old domain. So a link you never touch still sends customers and still counts.
If you haven't set that up yet, do it before anything else. It's the foundation for all of this. Here's how: How to Set Up 301 Redirects So Google Follows You to Your New Domain.
Once redirects are in place, updating a link by hand only buys you two things: a slightly cleaner, more direct path (no redirect hop), and insurance in case the redirect ever gets turned off. For most links, that's not worth a phone call. For a few, it is.
The links worth updating by hand
Spend your time here first. These are the ones where a direct link to your new domain pays off.
Your own listings and profiles
Anything you control, update yourself. Your Google Business Profile, Yelp, Facebook page, LinkedIn, Instagram bio, industry directories you pay for. These show your domain to customers in plain text, so a stale one is confusing even if the click still works. And they're easy — you already have the logins.
These overlap with your map listings, which matter for a different reason too. We covered that in Don't Forget Your Local Listings When You Change Domains.
High-traffic links that actually send you customers
Check your analytics for the pages that sent real visitors before the move. A supplier who features you, a popular local blog, a partner who shares your work — if people click it, make it point straight at the new name. A direct link loads a hair faster and leaves no room for a broken redirect down the road.
Links from trusted, well-known sites
A link from your city newspaper, a university, a big trade association, or a government page carries weight with Google. These are worth a polite email asking for an update. They're also the links you'd least want to lose if an old redirect ever lapsed.
Anything in print or on physical stuff
Not a backlink exactly, but the same idea. Your van, your business cards, your signage, your invoices, printed ads. These can't redirect. Whatever's printed is what people type. Update the artwork going forward.
The links you can leave alone
This is where people waste a weekend. Skip these as long as your redirects are solid:
- Scraper and auto-generated sites that copied your info without asking. You can't reach a human there, and they send almost no one.
- Old forum posts and comments from years ago. Low traffic, often locked from editing.
- Tiny directories nobody uses. The effort to find a login isn't worth one link.
- Dead or abandoned blogs where no one's answering email.
For all of these, the redirect does the job quietly. Let it.
How to find your links in the first place
You can't update what you can't see. Start with the free Google Search Console and look at the links report for your old domain. It shows who links to you, which pages they point at, and roughly how much. That's usually enough to build your short list.
Then sort fast. Make three piles: fix it myself (my own listings), ask for a fix (big, trusted, or high-traffic sites), and leave it (everything else). Don't overthink the third pile. It's the biggest one on purpose.
How to ask for an update without it being a chore
Keep the email short. Tell them the old address, the new address, and thank them. Something like:
Hi — we changed our website name from oldname.com to newname.com. Could you update the link on your page when you get a chance? The old one still works, so there's no rush. Thanks for featuring us.
Say the old one still works. It takes the pressure off and makes people more likely to say yes. You're asking for tidy, not rescue.
Updating links is the last 10% of a domain move, not the first. Get your redirects right, fix the listings you control, nudge a few important sites, and let the long tail ride on the redirect. For the full order of operations, see The Checklist to Run Before You Move Your Site to a Better Domain — and if you want to know what quietly sinks rankings during a move, read 5 Mistakes That Tank Your Rankings When You Change Domains.
Still weighing whether a better name is even worth the move? Start small. Browse names for your city and trade, or ask us about one specific domain you've got in mind. It takes a minute, and there's no pressure to decide today.